It depends! If you wish to brighten your under eyes, you must use a concealer shade that is one to two shades lighter than your foundation. On the other hand, while covering blemishes or redness, you must go for the same shade as your foundation. For Indian skin tones, which typically have warm or neutral undertones, you must choose peach, orange, or golden undertones to camouflage the high melanated areas and brighten the under eyes. If your concealer appears ashy, chalky, or stands in stark contrast with your skin or foundation, especially under the eyes, it is probably because of using the wrong concealer shade that’s too light for your skin tone.